- Second Chance AIHA ›
- Forums ›
- AIHA Dog ›
- Weaning info?
Tamara,
To respond to you I need to draw some important differences in how Dr. Dodds approaches (and approached with Chance) bone marrow failure in a dog. It is significant to note that she has been recognizing and treating this condition for a very long time. In 2007 even my renowned Diplomate Vet specialist was confused by Chance’s bone marrow failure and could only offer a guess that it might be autoimmune related. But as far as treatment, he offered little help or hope and prescribed only prednisone. Chance was not responding to this treatment.
I have helped many owners since then whose dogs had severe bone marrow failure. Many of the vets they were working with appeared to not be cognizant of how and why this condition appears in dogs. Nor in some cases did they understand how to properly treat this. Thus it also appears that they could not fully understand canine physiological response to treatment.
In intractable cases of bone marrow failure in dogs, Dr. Dodds knows from experience that many dogs have an autoimmune component and often autoimmune hypothyroidism. Many vets first seem to jump to the conclusion that this is a form of cancer. That essentially bypasses a series of diagnostics that Dr. Dodds normally recommends first before immediately doing a bone marrow biopsy. She points to investigating autoimmune hypothyroidism, a drug the dog was recently exposed to, a recent vaccination, toxic exposure, recent surgery, hormonal influence, infection or injury. You and I have talked about how I felt, from reviewing his blood work, that he was undergoing a inflammatory response to something and I thought that his digestive problems were related. A benign tumor probably wouldn’t be directly related, but if a spider, bee or snake bite occurred in this location and became infected it is possible that one of these insults could enhance an autoimmune reaction.
Years ago, Dr. Dodds recognized that bone marrow failure in dogs could be caused by an autoimmune attack on the precursor cells (stem cells) of the bone marrow by the T-cell lymphocytes. In her early career she had been involved not only in veterinary science but also has an extensive resume working in human hematology and immunology. Her experiences may have exposed her to the use of cyclosporine to treat humans with organ transplants. Clearly her understanding of how this worked in humans prompted her to explore using it in dogs with bone marrow failure and AIHA.
So this brings me around to how Chance was dosed with cyclosporine by Dr. Dodds for his severe non-regenerative anemia and neutropenia. She used “pulse dosing” with him, something she often recommends for dogs with intractable bone marrow failure. This concept is sometimes used in dosing with herbs. The idea being that constant exposure to an herb or drug on a daily basis begins to blunt the response by the body. Giving a few days off between dosing seems to resharpen the bodies response to the drug.
So she first started dosing Chance at a “Loading Dose.” (10mg/kg) The recommended higher dose for Atopica quickly brings the blood level up to a therapeutic dose, “jump starting” the treatment by saturating tissues. But to this dosing she also added the pulse dosing, so he received his Atopica Monday through Friday and had a drug holiday Saturday and Sunday. After 3-4 weeks of this dosing schedule she had me reduce the Atopica to the normal dosing. She continued him on the M-F, SS off, dosing schedule. Within the first 3-4 weeks he became regenerative.
I often read that vets want to test the blood level of cyclosporine to ensure that it is in the correct levels. I have explained the history of this with human organ transplant to you already. There were two formulations of drugs and they were being used interchangeably. It was not apparent until after some time that one formulation had a much more variable absorption in the body and patients were sometimes not getting enough of the drug, thus the eventual required testing of blood levels. When they discovered this it was recommended that they use the formulation that was more stable and absorbed at a constant rate. This is the formulation they use in Atopica and generics of this drug now for dogs.
So it isn’t usually necessary to test the blood levels of this drug in a dog because they are receiving the correct formulation that ensures proper absorption as long as it is dosed according to the recommendations and is being properly given without food. I asked Dr. Dodds about this early on and she told me not to waste the money testing. We would know soon enough if this was going to work and in fact she was quite correct.
But secondly, think about how Dr. Dodds doses these dogs with bone marrow failure, she uses pulse dosing. Taking the drug away for two days in a row should negatively affect the therapeutic value of it, right? But it doesn’t and Chance is a perfect example of that. The drug was MORE effective being given only 5 days a week with two days off. This blows the whole concept out of the water that this drug is only effective at a certain daily dose (to maintain blood levels) and any dose below that it is not effective. Your vet is telling you that the drug is either on or off, that there is no level of efficacy at a lower dose. From my experience it maintains a proper blood level even with pulse dosing!
So yes, I did targeted decreases. I used a 33% reduction rate, approved by Dr. Dodds. I had to fiddle with this a bit because Atopica only comes in certain capsule sizes. I extended this decrease period out a little longer because Chance had allergies and I wanted to keep him on it into the worst allergy season in the following year. This drug is intended to be given to dogs for a long periods of time for allergies and has been tested to show that it is safe and effective dosing this way. So if this were my decision I would continue it and begin the decreases as I have described, 33% at a time.
If there is a relapse it will be less complex to just increase the dose some rather than go through a loading dose to get his blood saturated again.
I would recommend you reconnect with Dr. Dodds about the reduction. I would trust what she tells you.
my best
patrice
If Ashki remains at 20% (at a stable value) that would mean that he has been and continues to be REGENERATIVE. Staying stable at 20% indicates that he is having difficulty with the process of MAKING BLOOD, but is making SOME blood and thus is only partially effective. There can be medical reasons for this that are not necessarily related to an autoimmune attack. Cyclosporine would neither help nor hinder these situations.
Often, as I have discussed with you, this is directly related to gastrointestinal problems with properly absorbing certain important nutrients or not being able to get those nutrients to the bone marrow properly (liver shunt.) So the cells that are made are flimsy and not viable or they don’t have enough of the proper ingredients to continue through the various stages and this is maturation arrest.
Anemia can also be related to kidney disease as the bone marrow is not getting enough stimulation from the kidney hormone to start the blood making process.
In addition, the thyroid must be providing the proper thyroid levels in the body to stimulate proper organ functions. If there is a state of hypothyroidism, the body is on Slow Speed and the marrow can’t respond well.
And finally, any condition like this may be related to anemia of chronic disease. If the chronic disease can be identified and treated then the anemia would resolve.
It would be important in my opinion to carefully research these areas before concluding that he will never get above a PCV of 20%. I don’t buy this.
my best
patrice
Tamara, with Bingo we started out on 25mg cyclosporine twice a day (Nov/Dec 2011). After a short while (not sure how long but not too long) he was dropped to 25mg once a day. He stayed on that dose for about 18 months. By this stage we had reduced his pred to 2.5mg daily. After that he went to 25mg every second day and still remains on that dose now.
Bingo has done this very very slowly, having relapsed twice. He didn’t seem able to get past the low/mid 30s with his PCV for some time and we had come to accept that as his new normal. We started reducing his pred at this point and then a few months later his PCV started bumping up higher and higher, into the high 30s and then into the 40s.
Love Vally & Bingo
Hi Tamara
I am really sorry this has been so hard for you & Ashki. You know we care deeply about you & only want Ashki to make a good recovery. It is so unfair when things are not straight forward & the answers are difficult to find.
I can’t put it any better than Patrice has and I agree with everything she’s saying about the factors involved for adequate blood cell production, also the possibilities she has mentioned. Any one of these things can cause inadequate or faulty cells. We are still suspicious that there is something chronic that needs to be resolved with Ashki.
Worzel was also non-regenerative (being ill for some time) as you know, but we eventually found & treated the problem after taking a few wrong paths. Ashki being regenerative & holding his own is such good, good news for now, Tamara. Take heart from Vally & Bingo’s story too – that gorgeous boy had a really rough time, but he did get better. Keep going – keep getting tests. Please keep talking to Dr Dodds & follow her advice as she is so highly experienced & knowledgeable on many things including bone marrow failure & thyroid function. Find & treat the problem and that PCV will go up – I don’t agree with accepting his current level as “normal” either. A human would go NUTS if their doctor told them that!
Sending you loads of love & hugs & positive thoughts
Sheena, Worzel & Ollie xxxxx
Hi Patrice, Vally, and Sheena, thank you so much for all this information. Sheena, I, like you and Patrice, worry that there is a piece of the puzzle missing. And Sheena, thank you especially for the “reality check” about a human going nuts — that is a very good point. Good news today — Ashki’s PCV is 30! I honestly was so worried that he would never reach normal. I can’t help but wonder if his kidney function has been impaired since early on in this journey (ok, let’s be accurate — nightmare!) as his serum protein and albumin have been sinking since early/mid May, so it’s possible they have been compromised since then from the pred. And as you mentioned, Patrice, the SIBO is still kind of a question mark. I talked with the holistic vet and we are going to add some rx probiotics; her experience is that by populating the gut with probiotics, the good bacteria “crowd out” the bad and repair the leaky gut. I am also going to reread Mary’s section on SIBO. I do have the kidney diet down now for Ashki’s glomerulonephritis and we are seeing small increases in serum protein and albumin. His Mg is still low, so I am reading about that and am going to be doing some more analysis of his diet. I continue to wonder about his high serum iron, any thoughts? Perhaps we should take this to Ashki’s thread, as we’re straying from weaning info?
Sending you all so much love and gratitude and many hugs — and scritchies to the puppies —
tamara and ashki xoxoxo